In short, for those who haven't seen the movie yet, Sentimental Value (Directed by Joachim Trier. Screenplay by Joachim Trier, Eskil Vogt; Norway, 2024) follows the reunion of a father and his adult daughters. The father, a film director, after a long absence is trying to reconnect with his family, but also to revive his film career. Daughters return to their relationship with their father from different positions, one from distance and interruption, the other from closeness and continuity. However, both remain tied to the same family schedule in which roles have long been assigned and experiences never defined. The family home where the meeting takes place becomes important as the place where the family history is played out. However, it is not some kind of story that can be told, it is more about depicting the structure of relationships that continues to shape the present. The story of the family house is not a story of space, but of presence. In this case, the house is what remembers, reacts, endures.
This opening immediately sets the film's ontological framework: things are not neutral, spaces are not empty, and life does not appear without the way it is staged, staged. The house is alive because it is a stage. Not because it feels, but because it enables events, relationships, roles to appear and play out. It not only bears witness to what happened, but establishes a schedule in which what happened can be repeated. Who speaks, who is silent, who carries the burden, who stays. In that sense, the family is the theater of life - a place where identities are not chosen, but assigned, where experiences are not only lived, but also performed, played out, often without awareness that they could be performed differently.
Excess of the past
The sentimental value from the title of this film does not refer to emotional attachment, nor to the warmth of memory, but to attachment to a certain scene - to a role, to a schedule, to the way the past appears. Sentimental here is not an excess of emotion, but an excess of the past. The one that remained trapped as a trauma, that could not become an experience. Something has sentimental value when it cannot be rejected, although it cannot be integrated either. In other words, when it is no longer actively present, but continues to govern the present. It is a form of attachment that does not produce a relationship.
This is a film about the theatricality of life.
Here it is worth discreetly recalling Samuel Weber's insight, namely that the notion of theatricality does not mean falsehood or inauthenticity, but condition the appearance of something. What cannot be set, repeated or performed in some form cannot become an experience. Without distance, without displacement—without what Weber calls displacement—there is no reality, only overflow. Sentimental value arises precisely where this displacement is blocked. Where the scene repeats, but does not move, does not change place. Where trauma is constantly played out but never given the distance that would allow it to become an experience rather than a destiny. In this way, the injury ceases to be an event and becomes a role.
Displacements
It's not an ending that closes the story, but an ending that changes the appearance mode. We no longer ask what happened, but how what happened could appear differently. Not to make it more beautiful, but to make it possible. In the end, everything boils down to one father's gesture. A gesture that can easily be read as redemption, but is more risky than that, it is an act in which love appears as a gift. A gift, in the Derridian sense, is possible only if it escapes the economy of exchange, in other words, a gift implies that we give what we do not have. What is not ours. The father's gesture does just that. He does not offer the truth about the past and does not try to correct it. It introduces displacement, or rather, the experience of moving into another mode of appearance.
Trauma no longer appears as an absolute immediacy, but as something that can be performed, repeated and shared. That displacement does not produce a lie. It produces reality.
In this sense, the reality in this film is not what happened, but what can be done without destroying life. Reality is not given in advance; it is constituted in a gap, in a distance, in a repetition that is not identical.
The final act of the film consists of the father's gesture, which comes late and without spectacle. He offers no explanation, no confession, no apology. It does not try to explain the past, but enables a different relationship to that past. He does not offer the daughter a new meaning of what happened, but the possibility of re-encountering her own experience in a different mode - with a distance that does not erase the pain, but makes it bearable.
The gift of love
The gift of love in the film is not aimed at reconciliation, nor at "closing" the family story. It is addressed as the possibility of liberation from a single version of the self. Her father doesn't give her the truth, because the truth wouldn't change anything. He gives what he has no right to possess, but can offer - time, space, a new scene in which the past no longer has to be absolute.
That's why the end of the movie is quiet. No catharsis. No closure. Like the house at the beginning of the film, the scene remains open - only now it is no longer the only one imaginable.
If reality is what it can be, then love in Sentimental Value it allows not to remain trapped in what we are. And not necessarily so that we would become someone else, but so that what happened to us would not forever determine the limits of our existence.
In this sense, love does not confirm identity, but expands it. It does not solidify the truth, but takes away its violent finality. Love, therefore, does not fix the past but creates the conditions so that the past is not destiny. And it is precisely there, in that silent displacement of the scene and the real, that the film finds its end - not as resolution, but as the possibility that life, although wounded, remains alive.
Big holiday discount on "Vreme" - subscriptions 25 percent cheaper until mid-January. Give it away subscription to yourself or to someone else, read what matters.
